87
COST PER HOUR
Management & Merchandising
Total Cost Per Hour
The most important information a Product
Support Representative has to help the
user manage his undercarriage investment
is Total Cost Per Hour comparisons
between various parts, maintenance and
service alternatives.
It isn’t important whether these cost per
hour comparisons are based on historical
or projected wear life and cost data. It is
very important, though, that they are well
identified and represent total life of the
parts, components, groups or complete
systems being compared.
A total cost per hour analysis may be as
simple as comparing the original wear life
alternatives of two different track shoes
(regrouser or run to destruction). Or it
might be as complex as to include the
entire undercarriage system, with a dozen
various maintenance, repair and/or replace-
ment alternatives over the expected life of
the machine.
In either case, the two important elements
that must be known or estimated are:
1. Total wear or service life of the parts
being compared.
2. Total investment over the entire life of
the parts being compared.
For example, to compare the total cost per
hour of two different track shoes, you
need the total life of each shoe until it’s
discarded. You will also need the total
user costs. These include:
Direct Costs
(Can usually be identified from documents)
1. Initial purchase price (separately or as
part of the track group)
2. Removal and/or installation labor costs
(if applicable)
3. Regrouser costs
a. material
b.labor
c. transportation and/or handling
4. Cost of hardware related to installation
and removal
Indirect Costs
(Usually hard to document)
1. Downtime resulting from installation
and/or removal (if separate from track
group)
2. User’s labor associated with instal-
lation, removal, handling and trans-
portation.
Finally, the total investment and expenses
related to the shoes being compared
should include the following investment
reduction factors. These are deducted
from the total of direct and indirect costs
to determine the user’s total net cost.
Possible Investment
Cost Reductions
1. Trade-in value received by the user
2. Exchange value received by the user
3. Scrap value received by the user
The easiest way to visualize and consider
all the above costs (and the comparative
wear lives) is to diagram them on Total
Life Scales. Here the above shoe example
using a three-way comparison involving:
a. Single grouser shoe (with no regrouser)
run to destruction, and replaced twice
to equal the link.
b. Extreme Service shoes (with no regrouser)
run to destruction and replaced once to
equal the link.
c. Extreme Service shoe with one regrouser
and then run to destruction to equal the
link.
This example contains all the above listed
costs and investment cost reductions where
applicable.